The Diecast Zone · Model Car Club Since 1994

Diecast Collector Forums

Eight forums, every scale, and thirty years of shop talk — new arrivals, restorations, reviews, and the finds you won’t see posted anywhere else, with the full archive back to 2002 restored and searchable. Free to Register.

8Forums
195,000+Topics
1,276,000+Posts
10,000+Members

A thought to ponder...
 
Notifications
Clear all

[Closed] A thought to ponder! Why is it that FM LE's always seem to increase in value more than DM's

12 Posts
3 Users
0 Reactions
158 Views
(@Larry Bahmer)
Joined: 1 second ago
Posts: 0
 

A thought to ponder! Why is it that FM LE's always seem to increase in value more than DM's



   
(@Bill Staalenburg)
Joined: 1 second ago
Posts: 0
 

Good question..I have heard that it has to do with advertising.

Franklin Mint has been in Parade magazine in the USA Today with Ads for their stuff as opposed to DM who other than the mailings you don't see anywhere. Bob K. enlightened me to the Parade Magazine ads. Once he mentioned it to me, I remember years back, they used to be in there every Sunday. I think that FM beat DM to the punch on the LE market with their cars. I think that part of DM's problem is they keep some of their releases around for years, so by sheer numbers, the price doesn't rise much because of the supply of certain models even though dollar for dollar they are better quality.



   
(@Leroy Butler)
Joined: 1 second ago
Posts: 0
 

Yeah, that is a good question. I think Bill hit on some valid reasons. For years FM had the name recognition backed by advertizing and were pumping out tons of merchadise. Non-diecast model product kept the name in front of buyers and helped to sell autos too. While DM had quality FM had quantity and again the name recognition thing paid dividends for them. Much more was chronicled about error cars and that may have driven that aspect of collectibles. but lest we forget the so called holy grail of the DM Pierce Arrow I think well see more of Dm prices going up especially now that they have more le's coming out and their reputation for quality becoming legendary.



   
(@ronald-w-jones)
Reputable Member
Joined: 6 years ago
Posts: 347
 

That brings me to another question........

How many Pierce Arrows did DM produce with opening trunk?:-/



   
(@Michael K. Welborn, Jr.)
Joined: 1 second ago
Posts: 0
 

Historically, FM has lead the way, they have a rich history of producing fine product. DM was always a marketer. FM had the higher end product and the strong flashy advertising push behind it. FM was a place the public could visit see and interact with.



   
(@Roger Pratt)
Joined: 1 second ago
Posts: 0
 

I agree, Michael, FM was very visible through ads in car mags

Sunday supplements and some tv. DM had some ads in car mags/Sunday sups, but not to the extent of FM. Also, early DM models were nothing to write home about including the P-A w/open trunk.



   
Richard Dube
(@nickies)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 5 years ago
Posts: 5840
 

Higher end product???????????????

maybe I don't understand your comment. Could you be more explicit?



   
(@Michael K. Welborn, Jr.)
Joined: 1 second ago
Posts: 0
 

Part of DM's solid sucess. Focusing mainly on their existing...

customers and their house list.



   
(@Michael K. Welborn, Jr.)
Joined: 1 second ago
Posts: 0
 

Historically...

Danhury Mint (Glendenning Companies then MBI, INC.) copied everything Franklin Mint did. Franklin Mint started as a manufacturer of medals and coins for collectors, coins for foreign countries, casino tokens, you name it. Franklin Mint had the largest staff in the world of some of the finest sculptors in the world. Many of which now work at the US Mint. People like Gilroy Roberts, William Cousins, James Ferrell, Anthony Jones, on and an. Franklin Mint designed and manufactured some of the most beautiful medals made, in the most varied topics of any company. Danbury Mint stuff was outsourced and never looked as good..not even close. Franklin Mints other items were much better as well. FM pewter was Fine American Pewter made right here in the USA at Franklin Center. FM made some very fine sterling silver etched collector plates, silver embossed plates, silver spoons, silver scultptures, etc. Some very slick american made bronzes. This all occured from 1974 ish to 1983 ish. In 1974 FM made its first porcelain item. It was the Andrew Wyeth Bowl made for FM by Royal Doulton in Fine English China. All this stuff was as nice as it got. Danbury Mint simply did not venture this far into the products. Franklin Mints sterling silver plates were made at their mint too using the same techniques as coining. Very beautiful items. Danbury Mint did a few silver plates but they were not original in design and often were just silver plate, while FM's stuff was solid. In the period FM stuff just looked the best. FM's medal series were pretty much household names. Sadly some of those people did not collect because of beauty or quality. I nice complete old FM set has good interest in Ebay these days.

Some of FM's first porcelain plates were hugh 10" Audubon Bird plates made of fine english china by Wedgewood. These pieces are masterpieces for sure. The colors and quality are unmatched. I have a few. All this stuff was in their musuem. FM also had the museum, and at one time tours of the mint and manufacturing. The stores also helped implant the FM name into the public.

Then at first FM was better in diecast etc... and also way ahead of the trend on pop culture collectibles like Monopoly, Harley, Corvette, etc.

FM's early managment under Joe Segel felt the product had to be 1000 times better than expected and they followed thru.

FM was harmed by the not quite accurate 60 minutes episode in 1978. Clearly there was more at issue here, because Columbia House sold collectibles and was a division of CBS....enough said. FM also over the years became careless with their huge and valuable mailing list. They spent a lot chasing after new customers with media ads, while DM focused on their exitisng customers.



   
(@Michael K. Welborn, Jr.)
Joined: 1 second ago
Posts: 0
 

Please note that I...

started my last post of with "historically." I am well aware of what FM "does" and "does not" do right now. That was not the point of the post.



   
(@Robert Scharf)
Joined: 1 second ago
Posts: 0
 

I missed the "60 Minutes" episode. What was it about?



   
(@Michael K. Welborn, Jr.)
Joined: 1 second ago
Posts: 0
 

The 60 Minutes Episode...

stated that FM stuff lost value after it was purchased...a blanket statement for sure as well all know. Interviewed 2 people who bought $10,000 worth of stuff and could not sell it for that price. And interviewed some coin dealers of all people who said the stuff was worth only melt. Presently, I have sold several FM medallic setc on Ebay at significantly above melt. 60 mins also claimed FM stated that the items were an investment...which was not true. Even one of the customers interviewed stated how beautiful the items were. There was no concept of collecting because you like the way it looks or the theme. It is foolish anyway to hoard items from a profit making company that will make as much of an item as it can sell unless you actually enjoy collecting. CBS' division Columbia House also sold collectibles. They were just trying to get rid of the competition. As a direct result of the 60 mins show, tons of FM stuff ended up on the secondary market and sales dropped drastically.

I just purchased the 1973 50 State Bicentennial Medal set off Ebay. This is one of FMs best. Perfect quality. This invovled 50 different artists from 50 diff states. A huge development undertaking. These medals were only $15 a piece and the quality can not be matched for even close to that price. The free album that came with the set is so well made you could drive a car over it and it would be perfect.



   
Share: