The Diecast Zone · Model Car Club Since 1994
Diecast Collector Forums
Eight forums, every scale, and thirty years of shop talk — new arrivals, restorations, reviews, and the finds you won’t see posted anywhere else, with the full archive back to 2002 restored and searchable. Free to Register.
Tim, as used by the D4C, the word "club" is termed very loosely and probably is within the legal definition. (I don't know as I'm not a lawyer). The D4C "club" is much like belonging to the grocery store club, Sam's Club, Costco. Those entities don't report finances either, there are no voting rights, etc.
That is the similarity.
However, the above mentioned "clubs" offer discounts and specials to their members. This is where the D4C differs. At the Die Cast Car Collector Club, the members pay a premium for the club's offerings. Still trying to figure that one out. . .
We all have opinions....and here's mine.
Many, many moons ago, while looking around for model car sites, I happened on to this one. I looked around the site, liked the way it was layed out. So I registered, paid my dues, and joined. To me the newsletter is a really nice "extra". I say that, because I'm always on the site here. I have gotten more information on diecast cars from the D4C than from anywhere else I can think of. Tony P. and others have been instrumental in my incurable addiction to these little cars. Why? Because they have brought us the news first on the cars that are being offered. Without the D4C, I would have never known why the FM Outlet store in San Marcos, TX was going out of business. I would have never known what incredible cars Danbury was producing, until I got the flyers DM send out to the general public. I would have never known about the fantastic cars that GMP is producing.
What is even more important is the friendly folks I've meet on this BB and in the Lounge. This means a lot to me. The people are wonderful. The enjoyment of the people is well worth the $30....and more.
Personally, I like things the way they are. I think Jay and all the crew do a fantastic job. Hats off them all and my sincere gratitude.
Me......I got no complaints. I recently renewed my dues, and I'll keep doing so.
But a word of caution to those that fire off open letters like this one. It is best to direct this sort of thing to the head person personally, not in an open forum. In a public forum, like this one, these kinds of open letters can backfire on you, and really stir up a hornets nest of criticism for the originator of the letter.
That my opinion...and my 2 centavos. I yeild the soap box to the next person.:D
Ditto, Michael. I second your dos centavos.
Very nicely said, Michael. I agree and would like to remind the naysayers that participation is voluntary.
Isn't this the same as Franklin Mint club fees
This sound exactly like many of the complaints heard
about FM. You had to join to be able to buy the car.
So it really became an expensive purchase. Same here we
join the organization to buy the DC4 car but many
support this and gripped at FM ??????? I believe
Danbury has a similar setup. I've been on some other
forums and in no time start asking for donations. Than
comments comes out, donations are payment for there time and efforts. I don't know about here (They may be needed) but the topic seems to come up on all sites. At least
we get a couple of newsletters, if were to stop, than
would have to think is the car worth an extra $30.
Michael, the complaint is not about the site itself. The site is EXCELLENT, the BEST I've ever seen
The bitch is about the worth of the newsletter and the fact that one is forced to subscribe to it just to get the new limited edition Continental.
As far as stirring up criticism towards me, well I would hope that the comments are taken in the spirit in which they are meant. To me, the requirement is unreasonable and should be abolished.
Why not just increase the cost of the car? I think the answer is that the cost of the car is more palatable if the fee (fee is the way I see it)is disguised as a perceived benefit. According to the Newsletter itself, the purpose it to reach the 1/3 of the membership who are not computer literate. Why force the rest of us to buy redundant material?
Maybe there wouldn't be as many takers of the car at $180 each. Just a thought.
That being said, I appreciate Jay's Olins willingness to allow my posts and their responses to be seen and discussed.
OK, I'll keep it brief...
1) The site is wonderful
2) The newsletter has improved, in my opinion.
However, were I not computer enabled, I don't know that
I'd feel that way. Seems to me if you load it with things
we've seen on the site (like new issues), computer
people see it as a waste. If you include only additional
info, hard copy members are out of the loop. Maybe a
list of new models could be sent out more often in a
simpler format, thus cutting down on layout time, with a
"real" issue sent out quarterly? I suggest this only
because I remember how frustrated i was before I had
my PC...I paid dues yet missed out on the Caddy (or
was it the Packard) because I got the info too late via
snail mail.
I work in publications...unless you view the newsletter
as a job, getting out one a month would be really
difficult.
I've also written for the newsletter, which makes me
less than objective.
3) Belonging to the club makes us eligible for the MKII.
Seems fair...it's a club car. Don't want to pay dues?
Take your chances on the secondary market. The MKII
might run low, like the Packard, or it might run high.
Maybe you'd get it for the extra $30 you'd pay for dues,
maybe not.
4) The wonderful people I've "met"...Mike, Doug,
George, Ed, Shiela, Bob, White House, Roland...make
my association here worth occasional irritation and
$30/year.
5) We can...and have...accomplished some pretty cool
things together. I like to belong. I like sharing your
lives, your triumphs and tragedies. I count on your
support.
Sorry..it ran longer than I planned.
Plus, I'd spend $30 on a single print magazine subscription, and I get much more valuable info here!
right on the button i agree with most of your open letter and glad to here someone else feels like i do . since legacy came in the club dedication to 1 24th mint die cast models has lessone by leaps and strides. i just saw mcnab at a car show pushing his overorice art the franklin mint as we once knew it is about gone and i see the club going the same way unless jay gets back to the his original reason for starting the club
Would you like some cheese with your "whine"?
Frank, my reply wasn't meant to be pointed at you personally.
I simply meant that airing a gripe like the one you have is best served by speaking to the main person themself, not airing it in a public forum. I can see your point and why you feel the way you do. I, personally, don't share your view.
However, I really like Mark's idea. A quick no frills notice of Up-Coming Issues by the model makers, and then a really professional color quaterly magazine with photos, articles, tips, and other useful and enteraining features.
I think this might be a good way to go, or at least consider going.
I could go on and on, but I won't. I'm not writing to make anyone angery with me. These are just my views and opinions on the subject, and are NOT pointed at any one person.
As I said earlier, I ain't got no complaints (how's that for a double negative)(one for all the English teachers in the audience). I like things just the way they are.
So there:p
You may have a good point..........
Last year, I have been told by a credible source that the production cost of a LE from FM is about $40.00 for a low content product as their standard.
Lets figure that there is some engineering work to do for this FIRST REVISED LIMITED EDITION of the MKII. Maybe the cost can jump a little bit. After all, this model has just the top removed and a booth installed.
Lets figure that it cost the D4C $60.00 for all these improvements. This LE is on sale for $145.00.
Where all this profit margin goes and why the D4C members cannot have some discount instead of being overcharged for an allready cheap FM rendition of a classic icon?
Michael, no personal offense was taken by your post. Thanks for giving your side.
I find this sort of logic overbearing and the whining boring
You say, "Where all this profit margin goes and why the D4C members cannot have some discount instead of being overcharged for an allready cheap FM rendition of a classic icon?" The man is entitled to make a living. Why are you or I entitled to know where someone else's profit margin is going? First off, the man took money from his own pocket as initial outlay to get FM to retool this model into a different diecast than they ever dreamed of offering on their own. He, or his staff, searched out the historic car to be redone. He didnt know if this image would sell or not so his money was at jeopardy. If he makes a profit on it, so what? And where is the gun to your head forcing you to buy it if you do not wish to? This whole line of complaining and whining is so boring.
When you make a superior club Frank, let us know. And when you tell us of YOUR rules will it be ok if we bitch and gripe about THEM? I have no problem paying club dues of $30 for the right to be able to buy a limited edition club car or turn it down if I dont like it and not get a newsletter at all. The newsleter is a bonus as far as Im concerned. If you think its content isn't to your liking why not submit something better to Jay to print in it. I may be wrong but I dont recall reading anything that you pitched in and subnmitted to spread diecast informational wealth. The man makes a living working and does the newsletter as part of his hobby sharing what he knows and learns with you the collector. Why not be more positive and constructfully helpful ibn thanking the man instead of howling at anything you find personally bothersome? And if you think the car is overpriced as you say, don't buy the damn thing. Where do you get off psoting about it and trying to spoil everyone elses enthusiasm over the new image? One would swear we are nothing but a bunch of whiny little kids. Some of us REALLY need to get a life!