The Diecast Zone · Model Car Club Since 1994
Diecast Collector Forums
Eight forums, every scale, and thirty years of shop talk — new arrivals, restorations, reviews, and the finds you won’t see posted anywhere else, with the full archive back to 2002 restored and searchable. Free to Register.
Message to those responsible for auction format
It seems to me that it is about time to change the quality of model designation in listing models for sale. There seems to be a wide difference of opinion on what mint in box should be. The four categories don't seem to be enough to acurately describe the model to everyone's satisfaction. I have always believed that mint in box described a conditon of a model that is in the perfect condition it came from the mints with all its paperwork and packaging irregardless of how many cases or times it has been out of the box. Catagories excellent and good are too meaningless and vague. Distressed is the only catagory that means anything.
Catagories of description needs to be revised.
Models are not always perfect from the Mints, as we all are painfully aware
Should a perfect model that has been displayed in a dust-free, smoke-free, direct-light-free environment be rated less than a model that has never been displayed, but has paint problems, glue smears, broken or missing pieces, etc from the manufacturer?
I understand what you're asking, but describing condition with key words is difficult.
Mint/Mint-In-Box and Distressed and the only two IMO that are easy to understand. Or should be. It is the in-between that is difficult because conditions can range widely. I really can't see improving on the system without getting into a confusing point system. Like Excellent-1, Excellent-2, etc. Kind of like the auction companies use for rating cars on auction. Because conditions are very subjective between seller and buyer. JMO.