Brooklin '69 Camaro Z/28

@moe-parr In my opinion, comparing early Brooklins to today's resin models is like comparing apples to oranges. There's no question that the resin models are more delicate than the early Brooklins with their molded in, painted over details. I have over 500 Brooklins and over 1,000 resin models. In all of the resin models I have, only two that had parts fall off. I never play with my models or take them off of their bases which is a big reason why they survive as well as they do. My late friend used to scrape my Brooklins for me and they became gems once the details were pointed out. I'm encouraged to know the details on the Camaro have also been scraped as it's a skill that I don't possess.

@bob-jackman I think the minimal trim detachment problems with resin models that you describe can be attributed to not handling them.  In my experience most of such detachments have occurred when removing resin models from their plinths.  Even when I try very hard to be careful I have caused trim bits to loosen or detach.

@tedweller +1

@jack-dodds +1

@jack-dodds I'm sure you are correct Jack. The problem I have is that I leave the resin models in their cases which creates a space problem. It would sure be helpful if the various makers would standardize their cases but I'm sure that won't happen.

@bob-jackman Same here. Also, when removing a resin model, a little bit of the material comes out with the screw. If you go to reattach someday, the connection could be weaker, especially if you are shipping the model somewhere.

@chris Sorry Chris, but I don't think this is a good set of photos for a comparison study - all of the photos of the Brooklin version appear out of focus, starting with comparing "Goodyear" on the tires.

Posted by: @rogerkerr

↑

"Sorry Chris, but I don't think this is a good set of photos for a comparison study."

Roger, I couldn't agree more. As I noted, my post was a "teaser comparison," using John K's YT review pics; it was developed quickly to appease all those interested in a side-by-side "shoot out."   I also mentioned that John M., who owns both models, will soon post a proper comparison.

Again, both models are very good, however, the differences can't be denied.  I have NO dog in this fight; I do not own either replica. My only '69 Camaro is 1/18 - and practically no one on the 1/43 Forum  cares about that!   😏 🙄 😀 

Posted by: @jack-dodds

↑

@bob-jackman I think the minimal trim detachment problems with resin models that you describe can be attributed to not handling them.  In my experience most of such detachments have occurred when removing resin models from their plinths.  Even when I try very hard to be careful I have caused trim bits to loosen or detach.

I also have re-attached to the plinths many models I retired and I never damaged one. In my opinion, because they are lighter, they are easier to handle.