The Diecast Zone · Model Car Club Since 1994
Diecast Collector Forums
Eight forums, every scale, and thirty years of shop talk — new arrivals, restorations, reviews, and the finds you won’t see posted anywhere else, with the full archive back to 2002 restored and searchable. Free to Register.
8Forums
195,000+Topics
1,276,000+Posts
10,000+Members
Notifications
Clear all
Forum 43
10
Posts
6
Users
0
Reactions
55
Views
Topic starter
17/10/2019 4:03 am
forum 43 mcoty
I'm in too. Anybody know their rules for selection? The selections are, well, weird.
17/10/2019 6:33 am
I think we'd need to talk about that....
....but all "Rules" or criteria should be fairly straightforward. As an FWIW, I think there should be two categories: A general one where everyone can play, and a panel of judges (maybe rotating each year) which review models supplied/loaned by manufacturers.
17/10/2019 7:52 am
The problem with supplied/loaned is that it taints the opinions.
I've reviewed models for Legacy and, try as you can to be objective, the freebie that has been given to you can affect your judgment. I trust the opinions more of someone who used their own money to buy a model.
BTW, re: the Hall of Fame list, I own 2 of the 5 1:43s.
17/10/2019 8:31 am
Interesting perspective...
A panel of "Judges" that is sent a car chosen by the manufacturer for review and then sent back would give the judge a hands on perspective of cars not in his possession, as well as giving a broad based set of criteria due to the number of cars presented. It would also eliminate the grossly subjective criteria often used when cars are purchased and then reviewed.
I think the idea of a 43 MCOY is a great one, and far more beneficial at getting our voices heard.
17/10/2019 1:00 pm
Well, the manufacturer can't resell that car as new once it comes out of the box...
it is always a problem allowing the reviewer to keep the item. It is very hard to get an unbiased report on the model, and if you do, it may be the last model that manufacturer gives out.
17/10/2019 2:05 pm
Agreed!
Let me say this unequivocally: Not some free car. The goal here isn't a way to get free merchandise. Rather, to give all manufacturers a chance to participate in a process by a leading website to have their products evaluated by enthusiasts. The cars would be on loan only, with no renumeration of any kind.
17/10/2019 2:17 pm
Absolutely correct!
18/10/2019 2:08 am