The Diecast Zone · Model Car Club Since 1994
Diecast Collector Forums
Eight forums, every scale, and thirty years of shop talk — new arrivals, restorations, reviews, and the finds you won’t see posted anywhere else, with the full archive back to 2002 restored and searchable. Free to Register.
The BMW. Opinions Sought...............
Three doors down to the left over on the 1^24 Forum a derisive comment was made that I believe reflects a commonly help opinion that is pretty well summed up by the observation of lovely to look at and drive, but a bitch to own.
I must declare that I have never owned one but driven many on dealer delivery runs. I can attest to the former, but have no experience of the latter.
None-the-less though, they are a popular car and one that people aspire to own where in Germany they often outsell fellow citizen, Mercedes-Benz. The NSW, Australia, highway police have bought some flash, big engined diesel powered BMW Road warriors to chase misbehaving Aussie drivers. In this role, vehicle reliability would be essential, I would have thought.
The considerable number of elderly BMW's still out there in daily use, can mean that there is a level of trust in their cars by persevering owners.
So, what gives with BMW are they really as bad as our forum poster colleague believes?
I have owned both and worked for both...
My experience,although years ago, that both are very expensive to own and maintain but my nod goes to MBZ. It tends to break down less than the Bimmer. The Bimmer seems to start to have issues around 70-80,000 miles while the MBZ starts this cycle around 120,000 miles. Others may have a different experience but this was mine. My oldest son has a BMW 550i and his has crossed the 90,000 mile mark and is having a similar experience.
David K Angeloni
I've had a similar experience with our Benzes
They are durable but when they get into the heavy maintenance mode around 125-150K miles, they can be expensive to repair. I've had a 300TD and a 350 SD. I'd buy either again.
I have several friends that are die-hard BMW fans. Their maintenance needs begin sooner but none of them seem to care much about it. They enjoy their machines. I have to admit, as a brand, they are as much a driver's car as any I've ever driven.
John Kuvakas
Warrenton, VA
I don't have enough money to devote to either.
Lol. That's okay Bob; the vintage ones you have are far more interesting IMO.
Thanks Jack. When the old ones break, and they do, at least I can work on them myself
I almost got a 3-series coupe in 2002 but reported high maintenance costs nixed the idea.
I stayed with Honda, having owned an '81 Civic and, at the time, had a 1987 Acura Legend. Both had bullet proof quality and reliability with affordable maintenance costs. I still have my 2002 San Marino Red Accord EXV6 coupe which has less than 50k miles. Besides, BMWs are so common where I live (Marin County, CA) that they're sometimes called Boring Marin Wheels.
BMW Loyalty
I have owned every Coupe, (2 door) model of the BMW 3 Series (now called the 4 Series), since the first in 1986 (six cars). They are responsive, a pleasure to drive, and quite good looking ,(imho), I take pride in my cars and maintain them with care. They have been remarkably dependable, and I have a waiting line of interested parties to purchase my old models. Yes they are a little costly to own, but a small cost for the enjoyment I derive.
You really can't go wrong with either.
Model to model comparison, the Mercedes will be more luxurious but the Bimmer more fun to drive on the low end. Get to the high end and the Mercedes becomes a beast in AMG clothes and the Bimmer gets really comfy in the 7 series. Neither are cheap to maintain but then again neither is a Corvette or a Cadillac CT6. Luxury and/or performance comes with an ongoing cost always.
I traded in my BMW X5 and now drive a Mazda-3 Hatchback. (PIC)
At around 150K the BMW front end sounded like someone dropped a large piece of plate-glass on minor bumps.
I went to the local BMW shop and they said it needed a new front suspension. Then they discovered the aluminum oil pan drain plug was overtightened and it needed an $800.00 replacement with an additional charge to drop the front suspension for access to the pan.
Then I suggested why not do the pan while the front suspension was already removed for replacement? I also suggested simply re-drilling the existing oil pan and tapping for an oversized drain plug. There seems to be no limit on BMW charges if the customer doesn't understand their plan to rip you off.
My X5 was garaged, no dents, no paint issues and overall in beautiful condition but I never knew when the next problem was going to pop up.
I had constant problems with tail lights and their flimsy socket design. I finally replaced the entire tail light units.
Here is the BMW on the last day I owned it and the fantastic Mazda-3 we are now enjoying.photo no longer available
photo no longer available
USAF 1958-62