I voted 63. I've always liked its square cut looks.

Lincoln. One of the best looking cars of the 1950s.

Yikes to both, but I voted Starlight because it's the wonkier of the pair.

I voted 1957, but I too dislike the Biarritz tail. Standard tail for me

Chevy wins for me. I like the Plymouth too, though.

Both are marvelous, but the Packard is truly amazing.

DeSoto. To me the 1958 Buick and Oldsmobile are the worst styled Big Three cars of the 1950s. I wouldn't call the DeSoto an oil painting either, but i...

Ditto.

The '55 is way sharper. Also it's red. It wins.

Agreed. I love the 1956's looks.

This time I'll take the Olds.

Thunderbird. More fully developed, easier to live with, and beautiful.

Tough choice, but the Packard is too cool to lose

1949. Terrific looks!

Gorgeous! I think I need to change my vote!