Poll: Which '57? (3/13/2026)

I had to go with a tie on this one, John. 

Both are exquisitely executed style wise. I voted tie.  My uncle from Virginia had a Buick all black.  That car purred when he came into town to visit my grandma 

I do not really care for either, so I just gave them a TIE!

@bob-jackman Hi Bob : The 1/18 1957 Buick diecasts I have are actually top-down convertibles from MotorMax. I have a blue/white version and a red/white edition. They were very inexpensive replicas but nicely done and quite large models.

NO-CONTEST!  OLDSMOBILE!  However, I love the Buick for '57 hands down over the previous '56.  Can't say that for the Oldsmobile, as I've always loved the '56 and '57. 

@michaeldetorrice

Buick for sure.

I love all that GM produced for the 1957 model year. Of the two pictured here, it's the Buick by a small margin.

Gents, thanks for your replies.