The Diecast Zone · Model Car Club Since 1994
Diecast Collector Forums
Eight forums, every scale, and thirty years of shop talk — new arrivals, restorations, reviews, and the finds you won’t see posted anywhere else, with the full archive back to 2002 restored and searchable. Free to Register.
John Bono
North Jersey
1. DeSoto
2. Chrysler
3. Dodge
4. Imperial
5. Plymouth
My styling rating:
DeSoto & Chrysler are very close and beautiful.
Dodge is in the middle by itself.
Imperial & Plymouth I don't care for either's styling.
I like them all but the gorgeous Plymouth is about the only 1/18 diecast replica I have from this group.
I'll take them in the same order they were presented.
John Kuvakas
Warrenton, VA
I'll take them in the same order they were presented.
Same, but I'd move the Imperial and Plymouth above the Dodge. The 300 is fantastic.
Retired in Dunedin, Florida.
Oh my! I now understand Goldilocks' dilemma! In reverse order from last: 5 - Dodge. This porridge tastes like gruel. 4 - Plymouth. This bed is too lumpy, fat front bumper sides. 3 - DeSoto. Too loud! That catfish mouth! Nuff said. 2 - Imperial. Almost grande; but just a touch off. 1 - Chrysler 300. Just Right!!
I’ll take all of them!
Zeeky Banutski
The People’s Republic of Maryland
Tie with a comment. Plymouth my dad bought a 58 the year I was born. I had great times growing up in that car and cried when he traded it in.
Chrysler is outstanding. The grill and the 300 badge are neat
Dodge very nice styling their best of the 50s. Taillights and grill.
Imperial one of the better designs of the late 50s Imperials.
Desoto got a sentimental vote but never like the grill. Now that really look at it the grill reminds me of the 58 Packard 58L with the grill pried open.
I'm in the same boat as Terry, not a bad one in the bunch. At least to me. I'd be on cloud nine to have any one of them in my garage.😊💯
Interesting selection. I would choose them in the order provided except I move the Plymouth ahead of the Imperial, the only one here that I would not want to drive daily.
The only one that I think improved from 1957 is Plymouth, which got my vote.
I will never forgive the Chrysler stylists who turned this:
into this:
Barry Levittan
Long Island, NY
For me, the tie for first is Chrysler, DeSoto, and Imperial, followed by Dodge and Plymouth.
Gents, thanks for your responses.
John Bono
North Jersey
Mindblowing that out of all of these only Dodge and Chrysler, although barely, remain.😟






