'58 Impala...to my eye, without the Chevrolet badges, I'd guess it was a Cadillac. So rich and upscale looking!

That is gorgeous, congratulations on your long sought-after addition to your collection! By coincidence, I just bought the two-tone blue one at a go...

I like the contrast, and the Alfa in particular!

Just felt like a good time to post these pics

What Frank and Graeme said.

With virtually identical sheet metal, all the trim details (of which there are many!) from front to rear make the DeSoto more interesting to my eye. C...

I surprised myself by choosing the Thunderbird. Maybe if the colors were different I'd have voted differently, but as presented, the T-bird looks bett...

Chrysler, Packard, Buick. GM still had that tall, bulbous hoodline going in 1956 while the others were much flatter and more streamlined by that tim...

Tough choice today, as I really, really like the '61 Chevy. Nice Ford for '61, too. But my heart goes out to that oddball looking Plymouth!

Same order as George - '59, '63, '61. 1959 is my all-time favorite Pontiac, perfect in every way!

Fun thing about your polls, John...when I see the title, I think to myself that I already know the winner. Then when I look at the pictures, sometimes...

The '55 looks a little simpler, a little "cleaner" to my eye so it got my vote. It's also the year I was born...

You'd look very prosperous pulling up in either one of these in 1960, but the Chrysler has the edge in overall styling, and again as yesterday, those ...

I love them both. Imagine shopping for a new car in 1960 and trying to decide between a New Yorker or an Electra 225! I think I would have gone with t...