Poll: Which Dodge? (11/2/2021)

In this instance I very much prefer the lines of the 1958 Dodge. The extra fluting at the front of the 1959 spoils the lines.

My vote goes to the FIFTY-NINE!  I thought the '57 and '58 Dodges were a big disappointment after the beautiful '56's.  But in '59, they got their pizazz back and were gorgeous!  

  These were around when I traded my '56 Plymouth in on a '60 Chevy.  I don't remember looking at either of these Dodges.  So I'm of the "no interest" section.

'58 for me. The '59 looks like an overly embellished version of the cleaner '58.

• Tue fir me. The both look great. 

58, the 59 went a bit to far for my taste.

58 for me.  The 59 seemed a bit overdone; especially around the tail lights.  I also preferred the grille of the 58.

Both of these Dodges are such great looking stunners !

58 for me.

Too much going on with the '59, so the '58 with the cleaner lines gets my vote.

Tie for me.  Both are beautiful examples of the second-generation Forward Look vehicles.  It's sad that many '57s through '59s rusted out prematurely.