For this trio, Lincoln, Cadillac, then Imperial. That red with white roof really suites the Premiere.
I agree with that other David^.
David Vandermeer
Corinth, Texas
I agonized over this and chose the Imperial over the Cadillac. Lincoln ruined their offering in the facelift of the beautiful 1956.
Retired in Dunedin, Florida.
I looked at each. Then I looked again. I walked away from the computer for awhile, and then looked at them again. SORRY, I don't like any of them! After the out of this world beautiful '56s the year before of all three, I'm appalled at how the '57s just went off the rails. Â
George Schire
Oakdale, Minnesota
Beautiful and yet widely varied automobiles. Each is a winner but in it's own way !
Caddy by far. 👀  Lincoln then Imperial. Â
Frank Reed
Chesapeake, VA
To my eye the Imperial looks a class above either of the other two.
Barry Levittan
Long Island, NY
Cadillac by a country mile; my fave Caddy of its decade. Imperial a respectable second and the "fin-spoiled" Lincoln last.
I’m voting with Jack on this one.
I will change it up.  Did not really care for the Imperial.  Maybe it was just the picture. I went with the Cadillac, Lincoln and then Imperial. IMHO.
There is only a couple of Cadillacs I like and the '57 series 62 is my favorite.Â
Cadillac
Lincoln, prefer the '56
ImperialÂ
`FoMoCo in '56; GMC in '57.
Imperial by a long shot.
Lincoln next and the way behind, Cadillac. Which seems so dated compared to the other two.
John Merritt
South Lyon, Michigan - USA