Poll: Which '58? (1/13/2022)

While the Edsel was a bit of a dog back then, at this time, I'd choose it because of its history and uniqueness.

While they are all chrome-mobiles I'll go with the Pontiac. I like the roof line and stance.

I like all three but the Pontiac takes it for me.

Even though it's my least favorite of the Chrysler Corp. lineup for '58, I still pick the Dodge out of these three.

I vote EDSEL!  I will forever love that grille.  

Pontiac for me too. Love its shape and rocket sides.

Pontiac wins this one easily for its styling; especially its roofline and tail end.  The Dodge is very nice too (2nd place) and I like the Edsel more with each passing year 3rd.  I would be happy to own any one of them.

Dodge for me.  Long sleek lines

Can't believe I chose the Dodge.  Pontiac appears heavy and cumbersome to me.  Dodge looks light, agile and fresh.

Dodge please, when the '57 - '59 came out I disliked them as too far out but over the years I grew to like them.  '58 & 59 I really dislike GM styling and Ford left me cold as well. '57 - '59 give me DeSoto or Dodge please.  

Today, I picked Edsel 1st. Then Pontiac, Dodge.

back then, I’d probably would have gone with Pontiac, Dodge, Edsel.

1) Dodge 

2) Edsel 

Poncho 

Thanks fer the pics !

Love all 3 but Pontiac is first followed by the Edsel and Dodge. 

@100ford2003, My pleasure!