Poll: Which '58? (1/13/2022)
'58 Dodge, Edsel or Pontiac?
Be sure to make your selection.
Of course, please “Reply” to share your comments.
Best yet please rank them.
Click on the picture to enlarge the image.
While the Edsel was a bit of a dog back then, at this time, I'd choose it because of its history and uniqueness.
While they are all chrome-mobiles I'll go with the Pontiac. I like the roof line and stance.
I like all three but the Pontiac takes it for me.
Even though it's my least favorite of the Chrysler Corp. lineup for '58, I still pick the Dodge out of these three.
Long Island, NY
I vote EDSEL! I will forever love that grille.
Pontiac for me too. Love its shape and rocket sides.
Retired in Dunedin, Florida.
Pontiac wins this one easily for its styling; especially its roofline and tail end. The Dodge is very nice too (2nd place) and I like the Edsel more with each passing year 3rd. I would be happy to own any one of them.
Dodge for me. Long sleek lines
Can't believe I chose the Dodge. Pontiac appears heavy and cumbersome to me. Dodge looks light, agile and fresh.
Dodge please, when the '57 - '59 came out I disliked them as too far out but over the years I grew to like them. '58 & 59 I really dislike GM styling and Ford left me cold as well. '57 - '59 give me DeSoto or Dodge please.
Today, I picked Edsel 1st. Then Pontiac, Dodge.
back then, I’d probably would have gone with Pontiac, Dodge, Edsel.
South Lyon, Michigan - USA
Thanks fer the pics !
Love all 3 but Pontiac is first followed by the Edsel and Dodge.